Avoid Shortcut Approach In Judgments; Courts Must Adjudicate All Issues

Case: Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee Bangalore vs State of Karnataka

Coram: Justices MR Shah and BV Nagarathna

Case No.: CA 1345­-1346 OF 2022

Court Observation: “Therefore, the courts should adjudicate on all the issues and give its findings on all the issues and not to pronounce the judgment only on one of the issues. As such it is the duty cast upon the courts to adjudicate on all the issues and pronounce the judgment on all the issues rather than adopting a shortcut approach and pronouncing the judgment on only one issue. By such a practice, it would increase the burden on the appellate court and in many cases if the decision on the issue decided is found to be erroneous and on other issues there is no adjudication and no findings recorded by the court, the appellate court will have no option but to remand the matter for its fresh decision. Therefore, to avoid such an eventuality, the courts have to adjudicate on all the issues raised in a case and render findings and the judgment on all the issues involved.”

Previous Posts

SARFAESI Rajasthan HC Imposes 2Lac Cost For Misrepresentation, Not Availing Alternative Remedy, Not Impleading Necessary Parties & For Keeping Court In Dark

Non Placing & Non Consideration Of Bail Order Vitiates Detaining Authority Subjective Decision: Tripura HC Sets Aside Detention Order

Preventive Detention Not Tenable When Other Penal Laws Sufficient to Deal with the Situation: Gujarat High Court

Writ Petition to Initiate In-House Inquiry against Judges Alleging Misconduct Not Maintainable: Kerala High Court

Can’t Upset Concurrent Findings on Facts Unless There Is Any Illegality, Infirmity or Error of Jurisdiction: Rajasthan High Court

Suppression of Information about Criminal Case by Candidate in Selection Process Can Be Ignored In Certain Situations: Supreme Court

Claimants Can’t Be Allowed to Take Double Benefit of Two Claims Filed under Two Different Statutes i.e. Motor Vehicle Act & Workmen Compensation Act, Rajasthan HC

Nothing On Record To Even Remotely Suggest That The Act Was Consensual: Supreme Court Upholds Rape Conviction Download Judgement

Keywords

Avoid Shortcut Approach, Judgments