Bare Plea of Mental Stress Cannot Vitiate Disciplinary Proceedings Without Medical Material, Rules Delhi High Court in Amit Kumar v. Union of India
Case: Amit Kumar v. Union of India and Others
Citation: 2026:DHC:9901-DB
Date of Judgment: 05 November 2026
Court: High Court of Delhi
Coram: Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Amit Sharma
Court Observation
“The mere assertion that the petitioner was experiencing mental stress on account of his family circumstances cannot, in the absence of material establishing the nature of the alleged condition and its relevance to the misconduct in question, be treated as sufficient to invalidate the disciplinary proceedings.”
Summary
The Delhi High Court has held that a bare plea of mental stress cannot vitiate disciplinary proceedings unless the delinquent produces material establishing the nature of the condition and its relevance to the misconduct. Amit Kumar, an ex-Constable (General Duty) of the Central Industrial Security Force, Unit CGBS, New Delhi, challenged his removal from service after six charges were framed against him under Rule 36 of the CISF Rules, 2001 — including a scuffle with a Delhi Police PCR officer on 27 June 2020 after allegedly being intoxicated, reporting for duty on 29 July 2020 under the influence of alcohol, abusing and assaulting a Sub-Inspector, threatening a colleague, and refusing a COVID-19 test needed for a blood examination — along with past punishments for similar conduct.
The disciplinary authority held all six charges proved and imposed removal from service on 27 October 2020, with no bar on future government employment; the appeal and revision were rejected on 4 January 2021 and 25 May 2021. Kumar contended that alcohol dependency and depression arising from his family circumstances lay behind his conduct, relying on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal v. Union of India. The Court held that he had placed no medical report, diagnosis or treatment record before the authorities or the Court, that his annual fitness records for 2019 and 2020 declared him fit, and that the plea of mental stress was raised for the first time before the High Court. The petition was dismissed, with no order as to costs.
Key Holdings
- A bare plea of mental stress, without material establishing the nature of the alleged condition and its relevance to the misconduct, cannot vitiate disciplinary proceedings.
- The Supreme Court’s ruling in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal v. Union of India does not by itself invalidate a disciplinary penalty in a case involving intoxication, refusal to undergo a blood examination, and past punishments for similar conduct.
- Judicial review of departmental proceedings does not reopen the evidence; the Court examines whether the enquiry was fair and whether the penalty is disproportionate.
- Removal from service is proportionate where six charges stand proved and the delinquent has earlier been punished for similar conduct.
Directions Issued
- The writ petition is dismissed; the removal order of 27 October 2020 and the appellate and revisional orders stand.
Background
Disciplinary proceedings were initiated against Kumar, a Constable (General Duty) of CISF Unit CGBS, New Delhi, under Rule 36 of the CISF Rules, 2001. Six charges were framed, relating to incidents in June and July 2020, and the disciplinary authority held all six proved, imposing removal from service on 27 October 2020. His appeal and revision were rejected, after which he approached the High Court under Article 226, contending that alcohol dependency and depression arising from his wife’s infertility explained his conduct.
Related Articles
- Disciplinary Proceedings Continuing Ad Infinitum Would Be Destructive Of Rule Of Law: Delhi High Court Grants Relief To CBIC Officer
- Court Can Quash Disciplinary Proceedings Considering Acquittal In Criminal Case On Same Charges: Supreme Court
Judgment Link: Read the full judgment (PDF)
Disclaimer: This is a summary prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official judgment for the authoritative text.

