Mere Filing Of Representation Before Authorities Does Not Extend Limitation Period: Supreme Court

  • Post category:Daily Judgments
  • Reading time:4 mins read

Mere Filing Of Representation Before Authorities Does Not Extend Limitation Period

Case: Surjeet Singh Sahni vs State of U.P.

Coram: Justices MR Shah and BV Nagarathna

Case No.: SLP (C) 3008 of 2022

Court Observation: “We have come across number of such orders passed by the High Courts directing the authorities to decide the representation though the representations are made belatedly and thereafter when a decision is taken on such representation, thereafter it can be said on behalf of the petitioner that the fresh cause of action has arisen on rejection of the representation. Therefore, when such orders are passed by the High Courts either relegating the petitioner to make a representation and/or directing the appropriate authority to decide the representation, the High Courts have to consider whether the writ petition is filed belatedly and/or the same is barred by latches and/or not, so that in future the person who has approached belatedly may not contend that the fresh cause of action has arisen on rejection of the representation. Even in a case where earlier representation is rejected, the High Court shall decide the matter on merits.”

“If it is found that the writ petitioner is guilty of delay and latches, the High Court should dismiss it at the threshold and ought not to dispose of the writ petition by relegating the writ petitioner to file a representation and/or directing the authority to decide the representation, once it is found that the original writ petitioner is guilty of delay and latches. Such order shall not give an opportunity to the petitioner to thereafter contend that rejection of the representation subsequently has given a fresh cause of action”

“The High Court has rightly refused to grant any relief which as such was in the form of specific performance of the contract. No writ under Article 226 of the Constitution of India shall be maintainable and/or entertain able for specific performance of the contract and that too after a period of 10 years by which time even the suit for specific performance would have been barred by limitation.”

Previous Posts

Keywords

Extend Limitation Period, Filing Of Representation