Haryana Civil Judge 2021: High Court Rejects Plea Challenging Allegedly “Disproportionate Marks” Given In Interview

Case: Moonak Garg and others v. Punjab and Haryana High Court and others

Coram: Justice Sureshwar Thakur and Kuldeep Tiwari Justice

Case No.: CWP No. 331 of 2023 (O&M)

Court Observation: it cannot be argued before this Court, that there was, as such, any reasonable likelihood of bias inhering in the mind(s) of the members of the selection committee, nor also it can be argued, that thereby there was any oblique/motive, thus working in the mind(s) of the members of the selection committee concerned.

…there is no material placed on record, at the instance of the petitioners, that any of the members of the selection committee, rather selected those candidates, who were closely related to them, nor any evidence has emerged before this Court, thus displaying that the contesting respondent concerned, invited only those candidates for facing the viva-voce, despite theirs not obtaining the minimum qualifying marks in the written examination, nor any cogent material has been placed on record, whereons, the learned senior counsel for the petitioners, thus can well contend, that there was any reasonable likelihood of bias working in the minds of the selection committee.

Previous Posts

Jammu & Kashmir High Court Grants Relief To Islamic Cleric Detained Based On FIR Which Concluded In Acquittal

Madras High Court Asks YouTuber To Pay 7 Lakh As Damages For Making Defamatory Video On “Gold Winner” Oil

Kamduni Gang-Rape & Murder | Calcutta HC Commutes Death Sentence Of Accused, Says Nature Of Injuries Not ‘Extensive & Brutal’

Supreme Court Criticises OERC For Challenging APTEL’s Order, Says Quasi-Judicial Body Can’t Be Aggrieved With Appellate Body’s Order

Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules | Transfer Beyond Society’s Territorial Limits Valid Ground To Revoke An Individual’s Membership: High Court

Keywords

Haryana Civil Judge 2021