No Fresh Injury After Eleven Days Does Not Disprove Penetration, Rules Delhi High Court

No Fresh Injury After Eleven Days Does Not Disprove Penetration, Rules Delhi High Court in Navratan v. State (NCT of Delhi)

Case: Navratan v. The State (NCT of Delhi) and Another
Citation: 2026:DHC:9866
Date of Judgment: 05 November 2026
Court: High Court of Delhi
Coram: Justice Madhu Jain
Proceedings: CRL.A. 144/2021 and CRL.M.(BAIL) 348/2021

Court Observation

“The absence of a fresh tear must be appreciated in the context of the time gap between the incident and the medical examination. A minor tear or injury may heal during such an intervening period, and the absence of a fresh injury after eleven days cannot, by itself, negate the allegation of penetration.”

Summary

The Delhi High Court has held that the absence of a fresh hymenal tear and of a male DNA profile, when a child is examined eleven days after the incident, does not by itself negate penetration. The appellant, Navratan, challenged his conviction under Section 6 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012, for the penetrative sexual assault of his eight-year-old neighbour on 5 June 2016. The medical examination at AIIMS, conducted eleven days later, found the hymen not intact but with no fresh tear, and the forensic report generated no male DNA profile.

The Court upheld the conviction but reduced the sentence from twenty years to fifteen years of rigorous imprisonment. It held that a minor tear may heal in the intervening period, that the absence of a usable DNA profile is neither a mismatch nor an exclusion, and that the child’s specific account of penetration, accepted by the trial court, was not discredited by either finding. On sentence, the Court held that the 2019 amendment enhancing the minimum sentence under Section 6 to twenty years does not apply to an offence committed in 2016, when the minimum was ten years extendable to life. The fine of Rs. 10,000 and the default sentence remain unchanged.

Key Holdings

  • The absence of a fresh hymenal tear, where the medical examination takes place eleven days after the incident, does not by itself negate penetration.
  • The absence of a male DNA profile, where samples were collected eleven days after the incident, cannot be treated as either a mismatch or an exclusion.
  • The mere possibility of tutoring is no ground to discard a child’s testimony, and variations in the child’s statements on peripheral details do not discredit her account of penetration.
  • The 2019 enhancement of the minimum sentence under Section 6 of the POCSO Act does not apply to an offence committed in 2016.

Directions Issued

  • The sentence of twenty years’ rigorous imprisonment is reduced to fifteen years’ rigorous imprisonment.
  • A copy of the judgment is to be sent to the trial court and the concerned Jail Superintendent for information and necessary action.

Background

The appellant and the child, then eight years old, were neighbours in Okhla, New Delhi. On 5 June 2016, he allegedly took her to his room and committed penetrative sexual assault, threatening to kill her if she told anyone. The incident came to light on 15 June 2016, when she complained of pain while being bathed, and an FIR was registered the next day. The Special Court (POCSO), Saket, convicted the appellant under Section 6 on 6 November 2020 and sentenced him on 10 December 2020 to twenty years’ rigorous imprisonment. He appealed, arguing contradictions in the child’s accounts, the possibility of tutoring, delay in reporting, the absence of a fresh tear and the forensic report, and pleading false implication over an alleged loan of Rs. 20,000 — all of which the High Court rejected.

Related Articles

Judgment Link: Read the full judgment (PDF)

Disclaimer: This is a summary prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official judgment for the authoritative text.