Scolding Employee To Maintain Office Discipline Does Not Amount To Abetment Of Suicide U/S 306 IPC: Gujarat High Court

Scolding Employee To Maintain Office Discipline Does Not Amount To Abetment Of Suicide U/S 306 IPC

Case: Sanjay Kanakmal Agarwal VS The State Of Gujarat

Coram: Justice Nirzar Desai

Case No.: R/CR.MA/19305/2020

Court Observation: “When an employee is scolded just with a view to maintain office discipline and out of fear or being hypersensitive, if an employee commits suicide, that would not constitute an offence attracting provisions of Section 306 of Indian Penal Code as the action taken by the employer was in good faith to maintain office discipline.”

“If an employer on finding the employee breaching the discipline of office, asks the employee that legal action would be taken against concerned employee and if after few days, the concerned employee commits suicide, it cannot be said that the threat to take legal action was given with a criminal intent to instigate the employee to commit suicide.”

Previous Posts

Law Is Worth Tinsel If Underprivileged Can’t Get Justice, Courts Need To Be Sensitized: Delhi High Court

CPC | Order VI Rule 17 Obligates Litigant To Make All Amendments Necessary For Determining Real Questions In Controversy: Delhi High Court

Judges Must Refrain From Making Derogatory Remarks Against Parties Unless Absolutely Necessary For Deciding Case: J&K&L High Court

Delay In Reporting Sexual Offences To Be Viewed Differently, Can’t Be Equated With Delay In Other Cases: Kerala High Court

Gauhati High Court Sets Aside Life Sentence Of Man Who Killed Wife While Suffering From Unsoundness Of Mind

Merely Because S.482 CrPC Does Not Prescribe Limitation Period Does Not Mean Parties Can Approach Court With Inordinate Delay: J&K&L High Court

Disciplinary Proceedings Continuing Ad Infinitum Would Be Destructive Of Rule Of Law: Delhi High Court Grants Relief To CBIC Officer

Actor Assault Case Kerala High Court Allows Crime Branch’s Plea Seeking Forensic Analysis Of Memory Card

Limitation Period For Filing Motor Accidents Claim Applicable Only Prospectively From April 1, 2022: Kerala High Court

Trial/Appellate Court Has Full Discretion To Order Sentences To Run Concurrently: Supreme Court

Bar Under Order XXIII Rule 3A Attracted If Compromise On The Basis Of Which Decree Was Passed Was Void Or Voidable: Supreme Court Download Judgement

Keywords

Scolding Employee, Abetment Of Suicide