Need To Separate The Chaff From The Grain Only Where Testimony Is Partly Reliable And Partly Unreliable: Supreme Court
Case: Balaram V. State Of Madhya Pradesh.
Coram: Justices B.R. Gavai, P.S. Narasimha, Aravind Kumar
Case No.: Criminal Appeal No. 2300 Of 2009
Court Observation: “The Court is required to separate the chaff from the grain to find out the true genesis of the incident.,”
“We find that when the Trial Court has disbelieved the testimony of PW.5-Ramkali and PW.6-Mulchand insofar as accused Uma Charan was concerned, it could not have applied a separate standard while considering the case of the present appellant-Balaram and Rameshwar (since deceased).”
“We are of the considered view that the testimony of PW.5-Ramkali and PW.6-Mulchand would come in the category of wholly unreliable witnesses.”
Previous Posts
Related Articles
- The Supreme Court underscores the need for careful scrutiny when examining the testimony of the sole eyewitness who also happens to be the complainant
- No Need To File Separate Final Decree Proceedings In Partition Suit; Trial Courts Should Proceed Suo Motu Soon After Passing Preliminary Decree: Supreme Court
- “Tutored” Witness Testimony Leads Supreme Court to Uphold Acquittal of 20 in Murder Trial

