Police Statements Cannot Be Treated as Substantive Evidence, Rules Supreme Court in Naresh v. State of Haryana
Case: Naresh v. State of Haryana
Citation: 2026 INSC 1220
Date of Judgment: 16 November 2026
Court: Supreme Court of India
Coram: Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh
Proceedings: Criminal Appeal Nos. 1137–1138 of 2014
Court Observation
“Where a witness departs in court from what he had told the police, the Court cannot prefer the police version over his testimony on oath.”
Summary
The Supreme Court has acquitted Naresh of all charges in a 2011 double-murder case, holding that statements recorded by the police under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure cannot be treated as substantive evidence. Every private witness who could have spoken to the occurrence had turned hostile and disowned their police statements, and the Court held that the courts below had wrongly treated those police statements as evidence of the facts stated in them. The Court also clarified that its decision in Bhagwan Dass v. State (NCT of Delhi) cannot be read as making a hostile witness’s police statement substantive evidence, and that the disclosure-led recoveries under Section 27 of the Evidence Act had not been proved.
Naresh had been convicted by the trial court and sentenced to death, a sentence the Punjab and Haryana High Court commuted to life imprisonment while upholding the conviction. The Supreme Court set aside the conviction entirely, holding that once the first information report and the Section 161 statements were excluded, the evidence against Naresh was of the same kind and quality as the evidence the High Court had found insufficient against his co-accused, who had been acquitted.
Key Holdings
- The proviso to Section 162(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure permits only one use of a police statement — to contradict the witness; even a proved contradiction serves only to impeach the witness’s credit, not as substantive evidence of its contents.
- Where a witness departs in court from what he told the police, the court cannot prefer the police version over his testimony on oath; a first information report recording hearsay, unsupported by its maker, is not substantive evidence.
- Disclosure statements were not proved in accordance with Section 27 of the Evidence Act, as the words used were never narrated in evidence; the recovery of the danda bore no connection with the fatal incised injuries, and the recovery of the gandasi was unworthy of reliance.
- Inconclusive forensic evidence, with the blood group undetermined throughout, and a medical opinion that only said the weapons “could not be ruled out” do not connect the accused with the deaths.
- On parity, once the first information report and the Section 161 statements are excluded, the evidence against Naresh was of the same kind and quality as that which the High Court found insufficient against co-accused Subhash, who was acquitted — the conviction could not stand.
Directions Issued
- The appellant is acquitted of all charges and is to be released forthwith if in custody; his bail bonds stand discharged if he is on bail.
- The direction for compensation under Section 357 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the fine stand set aside and are to be refunded.
- The District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani, is recommended to consider compensation to the legal representatives of Suman and Shakuntla under the Victim Compensation Scheme.
- The Registry is to communicate the judgment to the trial court and to the jail superintendent.
Background
On the night of 17 April 2011, two widows — Suman, aged about 35, and Shakuntla, aged about 40 — were found dead at their houses in Ranila village, Bhiwani, Haryana. First Information Report No. 23, dated 18 April 2011, at Police Station Baund Kalan, named only Naresh. The trial court convicted Naresh and co-accused Subhash @ Tinku on 20 February 2013 and sentenced both to death. The Punjab and Haryana High Court, on 8 October 2013, acquitted Subhash, declined to confirm the death sentence, commuted Naresh’s sentence to life imprisonment, and upheld his conviction essentially because his name figured in the first information report. Naresh appealed through the Supreme Court Legal Services Committee, and leave was granted on 5 May 2014.
Related Articles
- Eyewitness Testimony Cannot Be Discarded Merely Because Witness Is Related To Victim, Rules Supreme Court
- Gold-Holding Limits Rules Supreme Court
Judgment Link: Read the full judgment (PDF)
Disclaimer: This is a summary prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official judgment for the authoritative text.

