President Can Commute Death Sentence to Life Without Remission, Rules Delhi High Court in Jitendra Gehlot v. Union of India
Case: Jitendra @ Jitu Nainsingh Gehlot v. Union of India and Another
Date of Judgment: 17 November 2026
Court: Delhi High Court
Coram: Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Ravinder Dudeja
Proceedings: W.P.(CRL) 3053 of 2017
Court Observation
“Once we find that the Hon’ble President of India had all the relevant inputs and took into consideration all the relevant factors before passing the Impugned Order, this Court cannot substitute the opinion of the Hon’ble President of India only on the ground that it itself may have decided the Mercy Petition in a different manner.”
Summary
The Delhi High Court has upheld the President’s power to commute a death sentence to imprisonment for the remainder of a convict’s natural life without any remission, dismissing a challenge to the condition imposed on the commutation of the death sentence of Jitendra Gehlot. The Court held that judicial review of clemency under Article 72 of the Constitution is confined to the manner in which the power was exercised, and that a court cannot substitute its own view for the President’s once all relevant material was considered.
Gehlot was convicted of the murder of seven members and associates of a Pune-based family during a robbery at their residence in August 1994. The trial court awarded the death penalty in February 1998, the Bombay High Court confirmed it in July 1999, and the Supreme Court upheld it in September 2000. His mercy petition, filed in June 2001, was decided only on 18 September 2016, when the President commuted the death sentence to imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life, with no further remission by any authority. Gehlot challenged that no-remission condition, arguing that the delay in deciding the mercy petition violated Article 21 and that his prolonged solitary confinement, background, conduct and reformation had not been adequately considered.
Key Holdings
- The President has constitutional power under Article 72 to commute a death sentence to imprisonment for the remainder of a convict’s natural life without remission.
- Judicial review of clemency under Article 72 is limited to examining the manner in which the power was exercised, not the decision itself, following Epuru Sudhakar v. Government of Andhra Pradesh.
- A court cannot substitute its opinion for the President’s merely because it might have decided the mercy petition differently, once all relevant inputs were considered.
- The power to impose a whole-life sentence without remission in exceptional cases was recognised by the Constitution Bench in Union of India v. V. Sriharan, where ordinary life subject to remission would be grossly inadequate.
- The delay of more than 15 years in deciding the mercy petition was considered by the President, who had sought the Attorney General’s opinion on Shatrughan Chauhan; the delay could itself have justified commutation and did not vitiate the no-remission condition.
Directions Issued
- The writ petition stands dismissed, without costs.
Background
The mercy petition was filed in June 2001 and remained pending for more than 15 years. Before deciding it, the President sought the opinion of the Attorney General on the Supreme Court’s decision in Shatrughan Chauhan; the Attorney General recommended commutation, while the Home Ministry recommended rejection of the petition. The President commuted the death sentence to imprisonment for the remainder of Gehlot’s natural life, with a condition that there would be no further remission by any authority. Gehlot contended that the condition overrode the appropriate government’s statutory remission powers, but the Court rejected all his grounds.
Related Articles
- Seven-Year Terms Upheld for Five Men in Delhi Riots Culpable Homicide Case, Rules Delhi High Court
- Later Retraction Does Not Erase Earlier Testimony, Rules Delhi High Court
Judgment Link: Read the full judgment (PDF)
Disclaimer: This is a summary prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official judgment for the authoritative text.

