Bank Payment Without the Customer’s Acceptance Is No Settlement, Rules Kerala High Court

Bank Payment Without the Customer’s Acceptance Is No Settlement, Rules Kerala High Court in Mohamed Shafi v. The Banking Ombudsman

Case: Mohamed Shafi v. The Banking Ombudsman and Others
Citation: 2026:KER:85382
Date of Judgment: 10 November 2026
Court: High Court of Kerala
Coram: Justice M. A. Abdul Hakhim
Proceedings: WP(C) No. 17547 of 2026

Court Observation

“Only if the Advisory is furnished to the Complainant and the Complainant accepts the Advisory, it could be treated as settled upon the intervention of the Ombudsman as provided under Clause 14(9)(a) of the Scheme.”

Summary

The Kerala High Court has held that a bank’s payment of an amount directed by the Banking Ombudsman does not, by itself, settle a customer’s complaint: a complaint can be treated as resolved under the Reserve Bank — Integrated Ombudsman Scheme, 2021, only after the complainant accepts the Ombudsman’s advisory. Mohamed Shafi, a Standard Chartered Bank customer, alleged he had been induced into subscribing to eight life insurance policies between March 2023 and October 2024 on the assurance that the premiums would be paid from returns on his mutual fund investments.

The Ombudsman issued an advisory on 23 March 2026 directing the bank to pay Rs. 5 lakh towards the disputed premiums and Rs. 1 lakh as compensation for mental agony. The bank credited the full Rs. 6 lakh to his account on 25 March, and the Ombudsman closed the complaint the next day as resolved under Clause 14(9)(a) of the Scheme. The Court held that Clause 3(1)(k) of the Scheme defines settlement as an agreement reached through facilitation, conciliation or mediation, and the customer had no opportunity to communicate whether he accepted the advisory before the bank made the transfer. The closure order was set aside, and the Ombudsman was directed to pass a formal Award within three months.

Key Holdings

  • A complaint can be closed as settled under Clause 14(9)(a) of the Reserve Bank — Integrated Ombudsman Scheme, 2021, only where an agreement has been reached between the parties; settlement under Clause 3(1)(k) means an agreement reached through facilitation, conciliation or mediation.
  • A bank’s unilateral payment of an amount directed by an Ombudsman advisory, without the complainant’s acceptance of the advisory, does not amount to a settlement.
  • The writ petition is maintainable against the Ombudsman’s order, since the order is not appealable and the High Court can examine whether the Scheme has been followed.

Directions Issued

  • The Ombudsman’s order dated 26 March 2026 closing the complaint as resolved is set aside.
  • The Ombudsman is directed to pass a formal Award within three months of receiving a copy of the judgment.
  • The Rs. 6 lakh already paid by the bank will remain subject to the final Award.

Background

Shafi purchased eight life insurance policies between March 2023 and October 2024. He complained to the Banking Ombudsman that the bank had assured him the premiums would be covered by returns from his mutual fund investments. The Ombudsman issued its advisory on 23 March 2026, the bank transferred Rs. 6 lakh on 25 March 2026, and the complaint was marked as resolved on 26 March 2026 under Clause 14(9)(a) of the Scheme. Shafi challenged the closure, arguing that he had neither accepted the advisory nor agreed to settle the complaint.

Related Articles

Disclaimer: This is a summary prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official judgment for the authoritative text.