Pending Departmental Enquiry Is No Bar to Compulsory Retirement of a Judicial Officer, Rules Allahabad High Court

Pending Departmental Enquiry Is No Bar to Compulsory Retirement of a Judicial Officer, Rules Allahabad High Court in Praveen Sonkar v. State of U.P.

Case: Praveen Sonkar v. State of U.P. and Another
Date of Judgment: 12 November 2026
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (Lucknow Bench)
Coram: Justice Alok Mathur and Justice Amitabh Kumar Rai
Proceedings: Writ-A No. 4050 of 2022

Court Observation

“The pendency of departmental enquiries in respect of certain allegations which were taken into consideration by the Screening Committee is of no consequence, as the order of compulsory retirement is not punitive in nature but is based on an overall assessment of the service record of the officer.”

Summary

The Allahabad High Court has held that departmental enquiries pending against a judicial officer do not affect a decision to compulsorily retire him, since compulsory retirement is not punitive and rests on an overall assessment of the officer’s service record. Praveen Sonkar, appointed as a Civil Judge (Junior Division) in 2006 and promoted to the Higher Judicial Service in 2019, was posted as Additional District and Sessions Judge (Fast Track Court), Hamirpur, when he was compulsorily retired on 29 November 2021 under Fundamental Rule 56(C).

The Screening Committee had recommended his compulsory retirement at its meetings of 11 and 15 June 2020, and the recommendation was approved by the Administrative Committee and the Full Court. Sonkar challenged the retirement, contending that departmental enquiries were pending against him. The Court found no infirmity or illegality in the orders of 26 and 29 November 2021, holding that the recommendation was based on sufficient material available in the service record, and dismissed the writ petition with no order as to costs.

Key Holdings

  • Compulsory retirement is not punitive in nature; it is based on an overall assessment of the service record of the officer.
  • The pendency of departmental enquiries in respect of allegations taken into consideration by the Screening Committee is of no consequence to a compulsory retirement order.
  • A Screening Committee recommendation approved by the Administrative Committee and the Full Court, based on sufficient material in the service record, suffers no infirmity.

Directions Issued

  • The writ petition is dismissed, with no order as to costs; the compulsory retirement orders of 26 and 29 November 2021 stand.

Background

Sonkar was appointed as Civil Judge (Junior Division) and posted as Additional Civil Judge (Junior Division), Lakhimpur Kheri, in 2006, and was promoted to the Higher Judicial Service in 2019. The Screening Committee recommended his compulsory retirement in June 2020, the Full Court approved the recommendation, and the State Government passed the order of compulsory retirement on 29 November 2021, following a recommendation of the High Court dated 26 November 2021. He challenged both orders by writ petition in 2022.

Related Articles

Judgment Link: Read the full judgment (PDF)

Disclaimer: This is a summary prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official judgment for the authoritative text.