Courts Can Step In Where an Exam Answer Key Is Plainly Wrong, Rules Delhi High Court in Nasir Rasheed v. University Grants Commission
Case: Nasir Rasheed v. University Grants Commission and Another
Citation: 2026:DHC:10098
Date of Judgment: 05 November 2026
Court: High Court of Delhi
Coram: Justice Jasmeet Singh
Proceedings: W.P.(C) 13805 of 2026 and connected matters (W.P.(C) 14324 of 2026, 14331 of 2026, 14352 of 2026 and 14712 of 2026)
Court Observation
“The restraint laid down in Nandita (supra) is not an absolute bar. The same decision recognises that a key answer may be interfered with where it is clearly demonstrated to be wrong, that is, where no reasonable body of persons well versed in the subject would regard it as correct. That test is met where the error is apparent without any inferential process or rationalisation. The four questions fall within that narrow category.”
Summary
The Delhi High Court has held that judicial restraint in answer-key disputes is not absolute: a court may interfere where an answer is clearly and demonstrably wrong, without any inferential reasoning or rationalisation. The petitioners, candidates in the UGC-NET June 2026 examination, challenged discrepancies between the provisional and final answer keys in the Education, Urdu and Geography papers through connected writ petitions under Article 226. Ten questions were in dispute.
For six of the questions the Court found the controversy turned on academic opinion or inferential reasoning, the subject experts had already examined them, and no patent error was shown — so it declined to interfere. But four questions stood on a different footing: each had only one correct answer verifiable objectively from standard source texts and material in the public domain, with no room for reasonable expert disagreement. The Court referred those four questions to the respective subject experts for fresh determination, treating the petitions as representations, and refused to correct the key itself. It also held that a wrong key in a competitive examination affects ranking and eligibility, since marks determine merit position and whether a candidate crosses the qualifying cut-off — even a single mark may decide whether a candidate is considered.
Key Holdings
- Judicial restraint in answer-key disputes is not absolute; interference is permissible where an answer is clearly and demonstrably wrong without inferential reasoning or rationalisation.
- Where a question involves academic opinion or inferential reasoning, the writ court cannot sit in appeal over the experts or substitute its own view.
- A wrong key in a competitive examination affects ranking and eligibility, since marks determine merit position and whether a candidate crosses the qualifying cut-off — even a single mark may decide whether a candidate is considered.
- The National Testing Agency’s consultation with subject experts after receiving objections does not deprive those experts of neutrality or independence.
Directions Issued
- The four disputed questions (Question IDs 4818042982, 4818042962, 4818048438 and 481804978) are referred to the respective subject experts for fresh determination.
- The expert committee must hear the petitioners and pass a speaking order within three weeks.
- All petitions and pending applications stand disposed of.
Background
The UGC-NET June 2026 examination was held from 22 to 30 June 2026 across 87 subjects for Junior Research Fellowship, assistant-professor eligibility and PhD admission. Candidates objected to several answers; the National Testing Agency placed counter-affidavits with subject-expert opinions before the Court question by question.
Related Articles
- Suspended Students Cannot Write Exams Without Meeting Attendance Rules, Rules Kerala High Court
- Deemed One-Year Practice Exemption Only for Law Graduates Who Passed Out Before 22 August 2025, Rules Bombay High Court
Click here to read the full judgment/order
Disclaimer: This is a summary prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official judgment for the authoritative text.

