Jurisdiction To Execute An Arbitral Award Is With District Court, Not Commercial Court: Kerala High Court

Jurisdiction To Execute An Arbitral Award Is With District Court, Not Commercial Court: Kerala High Court

Case: M/S. Beta Exim Logistics (P) Ltd. V M/S. Central Railside Warehouse Co., Ltd.

Coram: Justice C S Dias

Case No.: OP(C) NO. 2400 OF 2022

Court Observation: Going by the scheme of the C.C. Act, the express exclusion of suits and applications reserved for judgment from the purview of transfer and the conscious omission of the provisions relating to execution proceedings under the Code of Civil Procedure in the schedule to the C.C. Act, urges me to agree and endorse the ratio decidendi in Shaji Augustine (supra), that applications mentioned in Section 15 of the C.C. Act do not include execution applications.

Thus, if a more expansive interpretation is given to the word application falling under Section 15 of the C.C. Act, to include execution petitions also, then necessarily all the execution petitions pending before all the civil courts falling within the ken of the C.C. Act will have to be transferred to the Commercial Courts, which in turn will clog the special courts with such matters. Moreover, no practical purpose will be served by such transfer because the Special Courts are not conferred with any additional power than that of the Civil Courts, to speed track execution proceedings, as execution proceedings have been omitted in the schedule attached to the C.C. Act. Without a faster timeline provided under the C.C.Act, to enforce an award, it is immaterial whether the award is executed by the Civil Court or the Commercial Court.

Previous Posts

Murder Charge Ought To Have Been Principal Charge, Trial Court Committed Grave Error: Bombay HC While Acquitting Husband In Dowry Death Case

Cases Pending For Years, Introspection By Judiciary Necessary; Otherwise People Will Lose Faith: Kerala High Court Issues Directions To Registry

Judicial Strictures Must Be Passed With Utmost Circumspection, Criticism May Have Devastating Effect On Professional Career Of Officers: Delhi High Court

‘Caesar’s Wife Must Be Above Suspicion’: Delhi High Court Upholds Dismissal Of RBI Employee

Madras HC Illustrates Parameters To Determine What Is ‘Urgent Interim Relief’ To Avoid Pre-Institution Mediation U/S 12A Commercial Courts Act

Keywords

Jurisdiction To Execute, Arbitral Award