Unqualified Person Appointed On Ad-Hoc Basis Cannot Claim Right To Continue In Employment As A Matter Of Right: Delhi High Court

Unqualified Person Appointed On Ad-Hoc Basis Cannot Claim Right To Continue In Employment As A Matter Of Right

Case: Dinesh Kumar V. University Of Delhi & Ors.

Coram: Justice Chandra Dhari Singh

Case No.: W.P.(C) 8449/2009

Court Observation: “Upon having perused the records of the case and having analysed the facts of the case at hand, it emerged that the petitioner did not meet the qualification criteria and necessary certification. Despite the opportunities granted, he failed to undergo the requisite professional or skill-based training and failed to furnish the certificate for the same. As such, an employee on daily wages or appointed on an ad-hoc basis, as a matter of right, cannot claim to be employed for a position to which one is ineligible.”

“Non-entertainment of the writ petitions in such cases is a manifestation of self-restraint by the High Court to avoid the exercise of extraordinary powers in each and every case at the throw of a hat, and to reserve the same for cases where the interests of justice and the Court’s conscience requires them to be exercised…This Court is also of the opinion that in a writ petition, delay/laches or mere technicalities should not be the basis for denying of relief and dismissal of the petition.”

“Industrial Disputes Act is a self-contained umbrella legislation that covers the panorama of employer-employee issues in the industrial space. As such, the benefits of the welfare legislation must be utilised by the aggrieved employees. Although alternative remedy is not a bar, the trend of directly approaching the High Court by way of a writ petition without having availed the statutory remedies, needs to be checked and frowned upon. “

Previous Posts

Account Statements And IT Returns Relied On By Arbitral Tribunal, Have Evidentiary Value: Delhi High Court

Government Order Cannot Have Retrospective Operation Particularly When It’s Not A Legislation: Kerala High Court

Industrial Dispute Act: Person Working in the Capacity of Consultant Cannot Be Deemed Workman: Guj HC Quashes Reinstatement Order

Weapon’s Recovery From Hiding Place Which Is In Exclusive Knowledge Of Accused Makes Such Recovery Absolutely Reliable: Allahabad HC

Industrial Tribunal’s Order Can’t Be Challenged On Disputed Questions Of Facts Under Article 226: J&K&L High Court

Tax Exemptions Given With Benevolent Object, Approach For ‘Exempting’ & ‘Including’ Subject Matters Under Tax Purview Can’t Be Same: Orissa HC

Writ Petition Against Private University Not Maintainable, Remedy For Alleged Arbitrary Termination Lies Under Civil Law: Gujarat High Court

Kerala Municipality Act: No Property Tax Exemption U/S 235 For Building Given On Rent Merely Because Rent Is Utilised For Charity: High Court

License To Use Software Is “Deemed Sale”; Service Tax Not Leviable On Ground That Updates Are Provided: Supreme Court In QuickHeal’s Case

Keywords

Unqualified Person Appointed On Ad-Hoc, Employment As A Matter Of Right