Indefinite Suspension of Liquor Licences Without Reasons Is Unjust, Rules Calcutta High Court in Barun Malakar v. State of West Bengal
Case: Barun Malakar and Others v. The State of West Bengal and Others
Date of Judgment: 13 November 2026
Court: High Court at Calcutta
Coram: Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray
Proceedings: MAT 812 of 2024, MAT 847 of 2022 and MAT 418 of 2023
Court Observation
“The State has absolute rights, but such rights should be exercised with fairness and reasonableness, free from arbitrariness, whims, or caprice.”
Summary
The Calcutta High Court has held that the indefinite suspension of temporary liquor licences without disclosing cogent reasons is unjust and unconscionable, and has allowed around 1,000 liquor shops in West Bengal to resume business for the balance of their licence term to clear their stock. The shops had been granted temporary licences for six months in October 2018 under the West Bengal Excise Rules, 2003. The State suspended operations on 3 March 2019, citing the Lok Sabha elections, but never permitted the shops to resume even after the elections, and eventually withdrew the licence category under which they fell.
The Division Bench held that while running a liquor business is not a fundamental right, a privilege or legal right once granted cannot be withdrawn without assigning a conscionable reason. The State should have disclosed appropriate reasons for prolonging the suspension, and its failure to do so was unjust and unconscionable. The shops are to be allowed to run from 15 December 2026 until the completion of the balance portion of their six-month term, so that the licensees can clear the stock piled up in their shops.
Key Holdings
- Running a liquor business is not a fundamental right, but a privilege or legal right granted by the State cannot be withdrawn without assigning a conscionable reason.
- The State’s power over liquor licences must be exercised with fairness and reasonableness, free from arbitrariness, whims or caprice.
- Indefinite suspension of temporary excise licences without disclosing cogent reasons is unjust and unconscionable.
Directions Issued
- The State is directed to allow the appellants to run their businesses for the balance period stipulated in their temporary licences, from 15 December 2026 until the completion of the balance portion of their six-month term, so that they can clear out the stock in their shops.
- All three appeals stand disposed of without costs.
Background
The appellants were among around 1,800 liquor licencees granted temporary licences for six months in October 2018. The State suspended their operations on 3 March 2019 citing the Lok Sabha elections, and the suspension continued long after the polls, with the licence category eventually withdrawn. The licencees moved the High Court, but Single Judges dismissed their writ petitions. They appealed, and the Division Bench allowed the three connected appeals on 13 November 2026.
Related Articles
- Police Cannot Curb Licensed Bar’s Hours on Mere Possibility of Crime, Rules Kerala High Court
- Bombay High Court Lashes Out At Hoteliers for Seeking Reduction of Liquor License Fees Citing COVID; Dismisses Plea with One Lakh Each Cost
Judgment Link: Read the full judgment (PDF)
Disclaimer: This is a summary prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official judgment for the authoritative text.

